The Love–Hate Relationship with Programmatic Display & Retargeting

If you’ve ever talked to a small business owner about programmatic display ads or retargeting, you’ve probably seen mixed reactions. Some love the idea of “keeping their brand in front of customers everywhere online.” Others hate it because it feels like money disappearing into a black box, with little proof of return.

So, what’s the truth? Let’s break down why these strategies inspire both excitement and frustration — and how you can use them wisely.

---

Why Businesses Love Retargeting and Programmatic Display

Keeps Your Brand Top-of-Mind

People rarely buy the first time they see a business. Retargeting lets you “follow” them online so when they’re ready to act, you’re the name they remember. In fact, 92% of first-time visitors don’t make a purchase right away, but retargeting helps bring many of them back.

Great for Long Sales Cycles

For industries like home improvement, real estate, law, or dentistry, buying decisions take weeks (sometimes months). Retargeting bridges that gap. Data shows that site visitors who are retargeted are 70% more likely to convert than those who aren’t.

Efficient & Precise Targeting

programmatic ads can target by behavior, interests, geography, even competitor visits. That kind of precision is hard to match in other media.

Affordable Brand Reinforcement

Compared to broad display campaigns, retargeting is often cheaper because the audience is smaller but already interested. Many businesses see conversion rates 2–3x higher from retargeting compared to cold display campaigns.

---

Why Businesses Hate Retargeting and Programmatic Display

ROI Feels Hard to Prove

Unlike Google Ads (where you see “this many clicks turned into this many calls”), retargeting usually shows impressions, reach, and maybe a few clicks. That’s harder for business owners to connect to real leads.

Attribution Is Messy

Did that new customer call you because they saw your retargeting ad? Or because they searched again on Google? Or because of your postcard? Often, it’s all of the above — but retargeting doesn’t get full credit.

Not Always a Good Fit

For fast, transactional businesses (pizza, nails, smog checks), retargeting may not move the needle much. Those customers buy based on convenience and price, not repeated brand exposure.

Feels “Creepy” to Some Customers

Let’s be honest — people notice when ads follow them around. Sometimes that builds trust, sometimes it backfires.

---

The Balanced Truth

Retargeting isn’t a magic lead machine. It’s a supporting tactic — a way to make your other marketing work harder.

• Think of it like a billboard that only shows to people who’ve already walked past your store.

• It usually won’t create leads out of thin air.

• But it helps convert the leads you’ve already paid for (from Google Ads, SEO, or direct mail).

In fact, campaigns that combine direct mail + digital retargeting have shown a 118% lift in response rates compared to direct mail alone.

---

When to Use Retargeting (and When Not To)

• High-trust, high-ticket, or long-decision industries: real estate, lawyers, remodelers, dentists.

• Businesses who already invest in lead generation (Google Ads, SEO, print) and want to maximize results.

 Not Ideal For:

• Low-ticket, fast-decision businesses: pizza, nails, smog.

• Anyone who needs immediate, trackable ROI without patience.

---

Final Word

Retargeting and programmatic display advertising aren’t “love it or hate it” — they’re love it if you use it the right way.

They shine as a supporting role in your marketing mix: making sure no potential customer slips through the cracks, while your main lead generation tools (Google Ads, SEO, Direct Mail) do the heavy lifting.

Bottom line: Don’t expect retargeting to be your lead engine. Expect it to be your closer — the steady reminder that builds confidence until your customer is ready to choose you.